Membership.io Blog

How to Develop a Content Strategy That Converts in 2025

Written by Nathan Schenker | Apr 9, 2025 8:56:50 PM

In a world where connection is the key to conversion, brands, entrepreneurs, and creators are rethinking how they approach their content strategy. Instead of blasting audiences with one-way messages across only a handful of platforms, they’re shifting toward a more intentional method. 

One that sparks conversation, shows up where their audience already is, and delivers content that actually sticks. The result? More traffic, more sales, and a customer base that’s not just engaged—but fiercely loyal.

However, implementing a content strategy that grabs attention and builds real authority isn’t an easy task. This guide breaks down how to build a content strategy that cuts through the noise, turns attention into action, and transforms your audience into loyal customers (and members). 

By the end, you’ll have clarity on:

  • What content strategy really means in today’s landscape
  • The core elements of a successful approach to content strategy marketing 
  • Tools to streamline content planning, creation, and delivery.    
  • How a membership can turn your content strategy into a recurring-revenue ecosystem

What Is Content Strategy? 

We interact with different content strategy examples daily. In our inboxes, on our phones, and even while scrolling through our social feeds. But if someone asked you to define content strategy, could you?

From a technical standpoint, content strategy is about creating, publishing, and leveraging strategic content for a personal or business goal. 

In practical terms, content strategy means having a clear plan for what you’re creating, why you’re creating it, who it’s for, where it will live, and how it will be maintained over time. It goes beyond content creation and pushes your brand into the thought leadership space while supporting business goals and delivering real value to your audience.

Alright, now that we have a content strategy definition, let’s shift gears and look at an example of content strategy in action.

Let’s say a business coach wants to attract more leads for their 1:1 consulting program. Instead of just posting randomly on Instagram, they build a content strategy focused on educating early-stage entrepreneurs about building a business and guiding them toward booking a discovery call.

They create:

Blog Posts — targeting SEO keywords like “how to start an online business”

Instagram Carousels — breaking down mindset shifts and business tips

A Free Checklist — “10 Steps to Launch Your First Offer” to grow their email list

A Nurture Email Sequence — that shares valuable insights and case studies

A Landing Page — as a part of their website content strategy that invites subscribers to book a free session

Each piece of content is tied to a unified purpose: to attract, capture, nurture, and convert potential clients across multiple online channels. In addition, it’s a clear example of how content strategy and digital marketing work hand in hand to bring content goals to life.

The Core Elements Of A Content Strategy

Every effective content strategy is built on four core components: Research, Content Pillars, Channels, and Metrics.

Research

Before you dive into writing creative articles or designing eye-catching social posts, it’s worth taking a moment to reflect on who you’re creating content for. Your audience is unique. The better you understand their values, needs, and experiences, the more strategic and impactful your content will be. So, how can you tap into what truly matters to them? With thoughtful, intentional research that helps you see the world through their eyes.  

Here are a few tips you can use to research your audience better:

Analyze Your Competitor's Content Their channels can be a powerful example of content strategy at work, showing you what topics resonate, which formats perform well, and where there may be gaps you can fill. Social media comments, YouTube metrics, and even blog interactions offer a sneak peek at what’s working and what’s not. 

Keywords And Search Intent With over 8.5 billion searches happening each day, Google is a powerful tool for understanding what your audience is actively looking for. Tools like Ahrefs, AnswerThePublic, and Ubersuggest can help you uncover exactly what they’re typing into their search bars. From simple how-to questions to more specific and creative queries like “what is content strategy in marketing”. These insights can guide your content creation and ensure you're answering the questions your audience is already asking.

Forums — Online forums like Reddit, Quora, or niche community boards give you a front-row seat to your audience’s real, unfiltered struggles and opinions. These platforms are full of questions, conversations, and pain points that can inspire valuable content. Or even spark an example of a content strategy built directly around what your audience is already talking about.

Content Pillars

Now that you have a clearer picture of what actually matters to your audience, it’s time to shape that insight into solid and definable content pillars.

Content pillars are the glue that hold your strategy together. They keep your creative ideas aligned, your campaigns consistent, and your audience connected. They also make content planning much easier. After establishing your pillars, you won’t be scrambling for content ideas because every piece of content has a predetermined purpose and place.

Here are a few approaches on how to shape your content pillars:

Start With Your Audience’s Biggest Questions And Challenges What do they need help with? What are they trying to achieve? This could include digital products, 1:1 services, or even a membership community that delivers ongoing value through exclusive content and connection.

Map Your Offers To The Content That Supports Them Each pillar should relate to a service or product you provide to be considered effective content.

Aim For 3–5 Core Themes Enough to stay varied, but not so many that your message gets diluted.

Channels

Despite popular belief, your brand doesn’t have to be present on every channel. A more sustainable approach is to focus on 2–3 channels where your audience already spends time, and you have a natural strength. Are you a strong writer with a knack for bringing ideas to life? Lean into that strength by creating SEO-optimized blog posts that highlight the value of your product or service. 

Or, maybe you’re more of a creative storyteller? Then, consider launching a podcast where you can share your ideas and connect with like-minded people. The key is to choose the right mix of platforms to develop your overall content strategy for digital marketing channels. 

Here are a few general channels you may include in your content strategy:

Social media Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok, X, Facebook

Email — Newsletters, nurture sequences

Blogs — Long-form articles for SEO and thought leadership campaigns

YouTube — Video tutorials, behind-the-scenes, brand storytelling

Podcasts — For building authority and deeper audience connection

Landing Pages — To provide your audience with detailed information. (Also, a good web content strategy example.)

Remember, choosing the right mix of platforms is key to building an effective content strategy. For some brands, that might even include a membership platform that gives your audience access to high-level content, workshops, or other resources in a distraction-free space.

Metrics

If your content strategy is how you speak to your audience, metrics would be how you read the room. They provide insight into what’s clicking, what’s being ignored, and where you might need to pivot your strategy. 

But, as you sift through the data for those performance-boosting breadcrumbs, remember not every number carries the same weight for your campaign. The metrics that deserve your attention are the ones tied directly to your business goals and content strategy framework.

Here are a few examples:

Awareness — Track reach, impressions, and website traffic if you’re trying to get on people’s radar.

Engagement Look at likes, shares, comments, saves, replies, and time on page. These metrics show how your content is resonating.

Leads or Sales Measure things like email signups, downloads, clicks to your offer, or conversion rates.

As you track your content’s performance, remember that data comes with peaks and valleys. The real story unfolds in the data over time. So, before you throw in the towel after a few slow days, zoom out and look at the trends across weeks or even months.

Content Strategy Tools

With the right tools, building your content strategy becomes a lot easier. You’ll save time, stay organized, and keep your content rollout consistent. 

Below are a few tool categories worth exploring to help you plan, create, and optimize your content.

Content Planning And Organization Use tools like Notion, Airtable, or Trello to map out your content calendar, brainstorm ideas, and keep track of what’s going live and when.

Content Creation And Content Marketing Whether you’re designing blog posts, recording videos, or creating graphics, platforms such as Canva, Figma, Descript, and CapCut can make the creative process faster.

Content Delivery And Hosting — Tools like Membership.io allow you to organize, protect, and deliver your content inside a branded space designed for your most engaged audience members. This can be especially powerful if you’re interested in building your own personal digital community.

Scheduling And Publishing To stay consistent, leverage digital publishing platforms like Buffer, Later, or Planoly to plan and automate your content across platforms. This helps you show up regularly without scrambling to push content out the door.

Analytics And Optimization Track performance with tools like Google Analytics, Instagram Insights, or TubeBuddy (for YouTube). These give you the data you need so you can understand what’s working and what still needs adjusting.

Repurposing Tools Stretch your content further with tools like Repurpose.io, ChatGPT, or Otter.ai to turn a single piece of content into multiple formats. Think blog strategy, social clips, and newsletters.

Why a Membership Might Be The Missing Piece in Your Content Strategy

If your content is gaining traction and your audience is growing, it might be time to turn that momentum into something bigger. What began as a single post or podcast episode can evolve into a thriving membership where your ideas spark conversations, foster community, and deliver ongoing value.

It also opens up new possibilities for how you monetize your brand and content. Rather than relying on social platforms to push your content out into the world, you’re creating a private space and community that isn’t controlled or influenced by algorithms, shifting trends, or your competitors.

And maybe most importantly, it gives your audience a reason to stay. A place to connect, grow and make progress together. In a sea of endless online content and overwhelm, a membership creates a sense of belonging, consistency, and value they can return to.

Final Thoughts

A thoughtful content strategy is more than a marketing tool. It's the foundation for long-term connection and growth between your brand and your audience. 

A strong content strategy sharpens your message, aligns your efforts with your goals, and helps you show up consistently where your audience already is. It transforms scattered posts into a clear, intentional journey that builds trust, sparks action, and brings people closer to purchasing from you.

And once your content starts attracting the right people, a membership gives them a reason to stay. It turns that hard-earned engagement into a community and offers loyal followers a dedicated space beyond the chaos of algorithms and competitors.

Want more information on how a membership can build off of your content strategy? Then, book a free call with a Membership.io expert today.